Ashmore Column: Trenton Season Ends Too Early
by Mike Ashmore
September 14, 2006 - Hunterdon County Democrat


The New York Yankees may have 26 World Championships at the Major League level, but they played a large role in ensuring their Double-A affiliate would continue to be stuck at zero.

The Trenton Thunder were nothing more than an afterthought for the Yankees when their minor leaguers needed the organization the most.

The Portland Sea Dogs -- affiliated with the Red Sox of all teams -- defeated Trenton three games to one in the Northern Division Series, a division the Thunder won handily in the regular season. But the roster they won with wasn't the roster that showed up in the playoffs. That roster was nowhere to be found.

Outfielder Vince Faison found himself sitting on the bench in the decisive Game Four, the same place he watched Game One from. If he ever wondered why his 14 home runs and 66 RBI weren't in right field, he only needed to glance towards the press box to see about 100 members of the Japanese media, watching the every move of Hideki Matsui.

Yes, Matsui was sent to Trenton to rehab during the playoffs, meaning one of the players who helped get the Thunder to the postseason would have to take a seat. Nobody would dare question the move; not Faison, not Brett Gardner, who sat in Game Two or Justin Christian, who didn't play in Game Three.

Their season now over, there's plenty of time for questions for a franchise now 0-for-their history in winning a playoff series.

Perhaps the biggest question came when Game Four was delayed by rain for 90 minutes after just one inning of play.

Matt DeSalvo was Trenton's starter in the final game, but could only pitch that first inning. DeSalvo, who struggled through a season in which he posted a 6-10 record and 6.40 ERA, is still considered a prospect by the Yankees. His team's season on the line, his organization wasn't willing to let him go back out there.

Conversely, Portland's starter Frank Brooks is a 28-year-old journeyman, a career minor leaguer. There are no restrictions on a guy like that.

He lasted six innings.

After Jason Jones allowed two runs, Charlie Manning made his third appearance of the series in Game Four, pitching three innings for the second time in four days. It was also the second straight day he'd pitched.

Ideally, J.B. Cox would have pitched in at least one of those games, taking some of the load off of Manning.

But Cox was also nowhere to be found.

Ranked as the number eleven prospect in the organization by Baseball America entering the season, Cox was allowed to leave the Thunder in mid-August to pitch for Team USA in an Olympic qualifying tournament.

Cox wouldn't return to the team until Game Two, and manager Bill Masse said Cox wouldn't be available for the game. Little did he know that Cox would be lost for the series and perhaps much, much longer.

Prior to Saturday's disaster in Portland, Cox was placed on the disabled list with what the team described as right elbow stiffness.

So instead of Cox pitching in Game Two, which Trenton lost, Jeff Kennard was sent to the hill. Kennard promptly imploded, allowing five runs without ever getting an out.

As for Game Four, Manning allowed the game-tying run in the eighth. Scott Patterson finished the eighth, pitched all of the ninth and came back out for the tenth.

Patterson said before Game Two that he struggled when he had to pitch in three innings. He was forced to pitch in three innings, and the results were expected.

Brandon Moss hit a walk-off home run off of Patterson and the overworked bullpen to eliminate the Thunder at Portland's Hadlock Field for the second year in a row.

But why did the Trenton Thunder lose the Northern Division Series?

As the Yankees T-shirts say, do the math.

Yankees 26, Thunder 0.

Contact Mike: mashmore@mikeashmore.com

All media files and information are property of Mike Ashmore and may not be copied, transferred or used outside this web site without permission.  All media outlets are not affiliated with MikeAshmore.com in any way.  Site is best viewed using Microsoft Internet Explorer.